Ice cream sandwiches are a delightful treat that combines the creamy, cold goodness of ice cream with the satisfying crunch of cookies. Across the United States, many spots offer their unique takes on this classic dessert. Here’s a roundup of the top 10 best ice cream sandwiches you can find in the USA.
List of Top 10 Best Ice Cream Sandwiches in the USA
1. Milk Bar – New York, NY
Milk Bar, founded by Christina Tosi, is renowned for its inventive desserts. Their ice cream sandwiches feature two soft-baked cookies packed with an explosion of flavors. The signature ice cream flavors like Cereal Milk and Compost Cookie are perfectly paired with their gooey cookies, creating a uniquely delicious experience.
2. Coolhaus – Los Angeles, CA
Coolhaus is a pioneer in the gourmet ice cream sandwich realm. Their creations are made with high-quality, artisanal ice cream sandwiched between cookies that are baked fresh daily. Popular choices include the “Built By Bake Sale” with chocolate chip cookies and the “Fried Chicken” featuring a savory waffle cookie with sweet ice cream.
3. Salt & Straw – Portland, OR
Salt & Straw, known for its inventive ice cream flavors, offers a unique twist on the classic ice cream sandwich. Their ice cream sandwiches use their rich, artisanal ice cream nestled between freshly baked, warm cookies, resulting in a mouthwatering combination of textures and flavors.
4. The Baked Bear – San Diego, CA
The Baked Bear is celebrated for its customizable ice cream sandwiches. Customers can choose from a variety of freshly baked cookies and ice cream flavors to create their perfect sandwich. Popular combinations include the “Bear Crunch” with chocolate chip cookies and birthday cake ice cream.
5. Serendipity 3 – New York, NY
Serendipity 3, an iconic restaurant in New York, serves an extravagant ice cream sandwich known as the “Frrrozen Hot Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwich.” This creation features a rich, chocolatey ice cream between two decadent chocolate chip cookies, offering a luxurious treat for chocolate lovers.
6. Big Gay Ice Cream – New York, NY
Big Gay Ice Cream is famous for its playful and delicious ice cream creations. Their ice cream sandwiches include flavors like the “Salty Pimp,” which combines vanilla ice cream with dulce de leche and sea salt, all sandwiched between a soft, chewy cookie.
7. Ice Cream Jubilee – Washington, D.C.
Ice Cream Jubilee offers a gourmet take on the classic ice cream sandwich. Their sandwiches feature unique and inventive flavors like “Mango Lassi” ice cream between freshly baked cookies, providing a refreshing twist on a traditional favorite.
8. Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams – Nashville, TN
Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams is known for its high-quality ingredients and creative flavors. Their ice cream sandwiches use their artisanal ice cream and homemade cookies, offering a variety of combinations like the “Peach Neapolitan” with summer peach ice cream and chocolate chip cookies.
9. Ample Hills Creamery – Brooklyn, NY
Ample Hills Creamery creates delectable ice cream sandwiches with their rich, homemade ice cream and soft, chewy cookies. Their “The Munchies” flavor, featuring pretzels, potato chips, and a variety of other treats, is a standout choice for an adventurous ice cream sandwich experience.
10. The Grove – Los Angeles, CA
The Grove’s ice cream sandwiches are a must-try for anyone in the area. Featuring freshly baked cookies and a variety of creamy ice cream flavors, their sandwiches are customizable and provide a satisfying dessert option for any ice cream lover.
Conclusion
From classic to creative, these top 10 ice cream sandwiches offer something for every palate. Whether you’re in New York, Los Angeles, or anywhere in between, these indulgent treats are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth and elevate your ice cream experience.
